Professor Bainbridge...on law, politics, religion, culture & food

Why I’m Opposing the SEC Proposal to Let Shareholders Nominate Directors

The Securities and Exchange Commission is now considering proposed regulations designed to allow shareholders to nominate directors and, moreover, to require the incumbent directors to place the shareholder’s nominee on the company’s own proxy statement and ballot, albeit under relatively limited circumstances. At first blush, the regulation strike many people as perfectly reasonable. After all, directors are elected by shareholders, so why shouldn’t the shareholders be allowed to nominate directors?

This argument, however, fails to put the SEC proposal in context. The SEC’s proposed regulations are just the latest in a continuing string of new corporate governance rules. Taken together, these new rules have significantly increased the regulatory burden on Corporate America. So let’s step back and look at the SEC proposal in its proper context: the recent corporate scandals and the government’s response. (For a complete roundup of my posts on the SEC proposal, go here.)